This production was shown on U.S. television as part of the Hallmark Hall of Fame series on December 11, 1984.
Tape version (EDDE Entertainment): 95 minutes
The TV version had several additional scenes, including one longish sequence of Armand and Marguerite in the country walking past a church and seeing a wedding and one of Armand and Gaston in a drunken celebration.
Directed by Desmond Davis
Written by Blanche Hanalis (based on the novel La dame aux camelias [The Lady of the Camelias] by Alexander Dumas fils)
Produced by Norman Rosemont
Original music by Allyn Ferguson
Produced by Hallmark Hall of Fame, Rosemont Productions
The film is based on the classic novel La dame aux camelias by Alexandre Dumas fils. It tells the story of the doomed love affair between a Parisian courtesan and her young lover. The plot is familiar from other film versions such as the classic 1937 production with Greta Garbo, as well as from Verdi's well-loved, often produced opera, La Traviata.
Marguerite Gautier (Greta Scacchi) is a beautiful young woman who lives the high life as a kept woman in the Parisian demi-monde, keeping company with aristocrats and the monied men. Armand Duval (Colin Firth), from a middle class family, crosses her path and falls hopelessly in love. Marguerite, obviously attracted by his devotion and his desire to care for her, abandons herself to him. And the lovers go off to the countryside-leaving the world behind them, at least temporarily. Confronted by Armand's father and asked to give Armand up in the young man's best interests, Marguerite makes the ultimate sacrifice and abandons Armand, leading him to believe that she is going back to her former lifestyle and lovers. Feeling crushed and betrayed, Armand returns home to his father.
When the opportunity arises, Armand seeks revenge. In this filmed TV version, when Armand returns to Paris and Marguerite sees him with another woman, she declares her love for him. He asks her to sleep with him and then insults her by sending her money the next morning. He then goes off to work in Egypt, still obviously smitten by Marguerite.
Some time later, by chance, Armand learns that Marguerite is dying, and he rushes back to Paris. By the time, he returns, she is on her deathbed, too ill to be aware of his presence.
Armand apparently remains faithful to Marguerite's
memory as we see him in a final scene as an old man putting flowers on
Comments about the Film
The film seems like a made-for-TV movie in its rather shoddy production values. Bottom line: It has excellent actors (in addition to Colin, Academy Award winner Ben Kingsley, John Gielgud, Denholm Elliot, and Billie Whitelaw) however, neither the script nor direction is quite as wonderful.
This film tries to update the classic story. There is an attempt to complexity what is basically a melodramatic novel for modern audiences: we see Marguerite in an opening sequence, being abused by her father and then leaving for Paris. This attempt to explore Marguerite's motivation may actually be a detriment; see the discussion of Garbo's Camille, whose character is established as light and capricious at the very beginning. And we also see a bit of her story before she meets Armand-she becomes the lover and model for a painter to escape starvation on the streets of Paris and is taken under the protection of a rich duke (John Gielgud), whose dead daughter she resembles. She even accidentally runs into Armand on the street but neither remembers the encounter!
Unlike the 1937 movie with Greta Garbo, which is so discrete and hemmed in by screen codes of the 1930s, this film actually shows the lovers in bed in a couple of scenes! An early bed scene suggests that Marguerite finds Armand both emotionally and physically satisfying.
The 1984 version does, however, have bits from the novel that are eliminated in some other productions; such as Marguerite's keeping a journal to be given to Armand after her death to explain her apparent rejection of him. The journal is the basis of the voice-over in the opening scene of the TV film.
Comments about Colin
Colin has a major role in the film, as Marguerite's lover. Colin is at his most boyish (except for perhaps Dutch Girls). The boyishness helps establish the character's immaturity and contributes to the believability of Colin's Armand as one who would sacrifice all for love. However, the passionate side of his character seems less emphasized, and there's little spark between him and Greta Scacchi.
Colin does get to be angry and even cruel in some of the latter scenes, but what characterizes the role for me would be all of Colin's delightful smiles: the smiles when he and Marguerite are in bed in the country, the smile when he shows Nanine the glass flower that he has gotten for Marguerite, the smile in the park after Marguerite invites him to see her.
|Colin's Armand seems tenderness and less passionate
than the role has been interpreted but part of that probably is what the
script calls for-in this script, the softness and devotion seem to be what
attracts Marguerite. (She alludes to this after their first night of lovemaking.)
Colin doesn't get to emote too much at Marguerite's
deathbed scene-unlike the opera where Marguerite and Armand have a whole
act for their deathbed scene. However, there is a scene in which a much
older Colin/Armand is laying flowers at Marguerite's grave (supposed
to be made to look old, but even in the makeup he looks about
* The name Camille, commonly used for the story,
is actually a misnomer. According to the introduction to one English translation
of the novel, here's the origin of the error: The first American translator
of the Dumas book in the mid-1800s titled it this way, although there is
no character named Camille in the book. The direct translation of the Dumas
title would be "The Lady of/with the Camellias."
The following is an excerpt from the Christian
Science Monitor review of Camille (certainly one of the least flattering
of any on these pages):
Nothing is so wasted here . . . as the viewer's time. This soap-operatic version might well have fit in a single episode of "Days of Our Lives." Instead, it is taffy-pulled into a seemingly endless two hours-while an annoyingly vapid and repetitive sound track keeps insistently reminding us that this is a poignant love story. And a good thing, too. Because neither Greta Scacchi in the title role nor Colin Firth as Armand seems able to raise the proceedings above the romantic fervor to be found in your average Close-Up Toothpaste encounter.December 1984
Again for sheer beauty and physical appeal--
In the book, there's a first-person narrator. The narrator encounters Armand as the result of buying a copy of Manon Lescaut (the classic 18th century novel about the forbidden love between a fallen woman and a respectable young man) at the sale of Marguerite's goods. It turns out that Armand had given it to Marguerite and wants it back as a remembrance.
In the book, Armand returns only after Marguerite is dead, and on the verge of a nervous breakdown, he aspires only to have one last glimpse of his dead lover. To achieve this desire, Armand arranges to have Marguerite's body moved to a better part of the cemetery. The transfer of the body is described by the first-person narrator:
A great white shroud covered the corpse, closely outlining some of its contours. This shroud was almost completely eaten around at one end, and left one of the feet visible. . . . It was terrible to see, it is horrible to relate. The eyes were nothing but two holes, the lips had disappeared, and the white teeth were tightly set . . . yet I recognized in this face the joyous white and rose face I had seen so often.
Here is the narrator's description of Marguerite alive:
Set in an oval of indescribable grace, two black eyes, surmounted by eyebrows of so pure a curve that it seemed as if painted. . . . The hair black as jet, waving naturally or not, was parted on the forehead in two large folds and draped over the head, leaving in sight just the tips of the ears, in which glittered two diamonds, worth four to five thousand francs each. How it was that her ardent life had left on Marguerite's face the virginal, almost childlike, expression, which characterized it, is a problem which we can state but state, without attempting to solve it. . . ..
For twenty-five days of the month the camellias
were white, and for five they were red; . . . she was never seen with any
flowers but camellias.
The Garbo Film
Garbo is established right at the beginning of the film as carefree and capricious-buying camellias at a dizzingly pace. The believability of the film is enhanced by Greta's classic, arresting beauty and a good performance by Robert Taylor (one of his best performances in my opinion and who plays a more mature Armand. He is blessed with some sharper lines and verbal repartee with Marguerite).
Garbo was nominated for an Oscar for this film,
but didn't receive the statue.
The opera was made into a fairly good film by
Franco Zeffirelli in 1982, with Placido Domingo as Alfredo (the Armand
role) and Teresa Strattas as Violetta (the Marguerite role).
To accompany his full, loose hairstyle, Armand wears lightish-color beaver hats, which to me are not the most attractive-give me the Darcy beaver hats anytime.
The tie that he has on seems the most exaggerated of any that Colin's roles require him to wear. (Looks a bit uncomfortable?)
And is the tropical hat the widest brimmed hat he wears in a film?
And isn't the Russian hat one of the silliest?
These ratings are from members of the Friends
of Firth group.
Janet's personal ratings;* which translates, into how often do you feel
Compiled and written by Janet